FeedProjects
Developers
Settings
๐ŸŽ‰ A new chapter begins: Boardroom has joined Agora
Learn more
protocol logo
Explore / Projects
Aave

Insights

Proposals

Discussions

Members

Information

Reports

Create Proposal

Aave

InsightsProposalsDiscussionsMembersInformationReports
Proposal
Back to Proposals
closedEnded 3 years ago ยท Snapshot (Offchain)

[ARFC] Cancel Llama Service Provider Stream

By 0x329c...543eD4

Title: [ARFC] Cancel Llama Service Provider Stream Author: Marc Zeller @marczeller - Aave-Chan Initiative Date: 2023-07-30

Summary

This ARFC proposes to cancel the Llama stream from the Aave DAO

Motivation

Llama has historically been a service provider for the Aave DAO and has made numerous contributions. However, during their tenure, there have been several instances where Llamaโ€™s performance has fallen short of expectations.

For instance:

  • Llamaโ€™s handling of the crucial CRV AIP was a clear demonstration of their inability to deliver a much-needed payload in a timely manner. The delay in execution resulted in an additional cost of approximately $1 million for the DAO due to the increased valuation of CRV. This incident underscores the need for service providers who can reliably deliver on their commitments and highlights Llamaโ€™s underqualification for the task at hand.
  • Despite receiving $1.5 million from the DAO, Llama charged third parties for consulting services related to Aave, including teams seeking asset listings.
  • As treasury managers, Llama failed to ensure that the collector contract had an adequate aUSDC balance. This oversight resulted in several service providers going unpaid for weeks, tarnishing the DAOโ€™s brand and reputationโ€ฆ

Given these circumstances, we believe that the most beneficial course of action for the Aave DAO is to end our relationship with Llama. This will allow the DAO to reassess its needs and budget for a new service provider.

The ACI and other service providers will complete any outstanding tasks from Llamaโ€™s engagement at no additional cost to the DAO.

By terminating Llamaโ€™s stream early, the DAO treasury can save up to approximately $240k. These funds can then be reallocated to other initiatives, ensuring the most efficient use of the DAOโ€™s resources.

Specification

The AIP will call the cancelStream() method of the Ecosystem Reserve and Aave Collector contracts. The details are as follows:

  • Ecosystem Reserve Contract: 0x25F2226B597E8F9514B3F68F00f494cF4f286491
  • Stream: 100001
  • Aave Collector Contract: 0x464C71f6c2F760DdA6093dCB91C24c39e5d6e18c
  • Stream: 100003
  • Address: 0xb428C6812E53F843185986472bb7c1E25632e0f7

Disclaimer

The Aave-Chan Initiative is not presenting this ARFC on behalf of any third party and is not compensated for creating this ARFC.

Next Steps

  • If the community approves ARFC via Snapshot vote, Publication of an AIP implementation.

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

Continue Reading
Connect Wallet to Add Note
0
Votes 12856
VoterCast PowerVote & Rationale
0x329c...543eD4
248,965

YAE (Cancel Stream)

FranklinDAO (Prev. Penn Blockchain)
106,783

Reduce Stream

0xdC1F...f5E432
106,666

Reduce Stream

0x732a...79B848
106,425

Reduce Stream

0xaFDA...353a6E
97,048

YAE (Cancel Stream)

SHOW MORE
VOTE POWER
0
Connect Wallet
Proposal Status
  • Mon July 31 2023, 09:46 amVoting Period Starts
  • Thu August 03 2023, 09:46 amEnd Voting Period
Current Results

1-Reduce Stream

657,725.111

55.75%

2-YAE (Cancel Stream)

521,569.42

44.21%

3-ABSTAIN

359.404

0.03%
Quorum 1.18M/320,000
DocumentationBrandingContact Us