[Temp Check] Should Uniswap Distribute UNI to Liquidity Providers?
Background:
Uniswap’s genesis liquidity incentive program ends on Nov 17. The existing program distributed 20 million UNI to LPs over 2 months, split evenly between the WBTC/ETH, USDC/ETH, USDT/ETH, and DAI/ETH pools. This works out to 2.5 million UNI per pool, per month.
Benefits of UNI distribution to LPs:
- Ongoing incentives allows UNI to be distributed to those providing value in the form of liquidity
- The incentivized pools are likely to remain the most liquid DEX pair on Ethereum, providing a venue to trade against ETH at virtually any size with zero slippage.
- Reduced incentives prevents UNI from being distributed ‘too fast’, marked by all tokens being distributed before the Foundation’s four year vesting has passed.
Drawbacks of UNI distribution to LPs:
- Ongoing incentives result in UNI largely being ‘farmed and dumped’ to earn yield. See ETH USD Yield Farm, Pickle, Harvest and Alpha.
- Reduced incentives means UNI is distributed slower.
- Incentivizing the same pools can be seen as choosing ‘winners’ by selecting WBTC as THE Bitcoin on Ethereum and favoring certain stablecoins over others.
Proposed new distribution:
Distribute UNI for an additional 2 months from the time this proposal is adopted and executed by governance. Distribute to the same 4 pools, but at half the rate of the genesis distribution. This works out to 1.25 million UNI per month to each of the 4 covered pools (WBTC/ETH, USDC/ETH, USDT/ETH, DAI/ETH), for a total of 5M UNI per month, or 10M UNI total over the next 2 months.
Please see the liquidity incentive governance plan document for full details and timelines.
Temperature check question:
Should Uniswap distribute UNI to liquidity providers per the specifications outlined above?
Next steps:
The snapshot poll will be live for 3 days. If the poll passes with a minimum of 25,000 UNI in support, this proposal will move forward to the consensus check phase. Details about the Uniswap governance process can be found here.
| Voter | Cast Power | Vote & Rationale |
|---|---|---|
0x7e4A...8B19Fa | 15.459M | Yes, I support this proposal |
0x8d07...e6A265 | 1.007M | Yes, I support this proposal |
0x4649...ea392e | 385,997 | No, I don't support this proposal |
0x8CCb...D6c9F5 | 43,448 | No, I don't support this proposal |
0xc193...5b59Cd | 18,920 | Yes, I support this proposal |
VOTE POWER
Proposal Status
- Mon November 16 2020, 08:00 pmVoting Period Starts
- Thu November 19 2020, 08:00 pmEnd Voting Period
Current Results
1-Yes, I support this proposal
16.521M
2-No, I don't support this proposal
467,760.293
3-Abstain
452.11
