Status: Discussion, Round 2 Author: Greg Bresnitz, Laura Jamarillo, Chuck Anderson, Alex Zhang, Yuri Rybak Date: December 14, 2021

Background:

We’ve collectively voted down the previous proposal around these benefits to focus on some granular distinctions flagged by the community. The following benefits are currently underway:

FWB Birds 3D Sculpture Raffle

Snapshot: December 8, 2021 Eight wallets will be randomly selected to receive first ever FWB Bird sculptures, mailed to an address of your choice.

FWB NFT Guest List Access

Snapshot: January 1, 2021 Holders of all 8 during this Snapshot will receive 2022 green-list access to future FWB.art native edition & FWB curated drops. This access will primarily be delivered through the #NFT-General-Chat.

For clarity, ‘green-list’ is a synonym with ‘white-list’, a term we are trying to phase out due to its problematic connotations

The subject of this proposal will be the nature of NFT Channel Access afforded 8/8 holders.

NFT Channel Access:

This vote is to determine the nature of access, granted to holders of all 8/8 FWB.ART MIAMI NFTs, with specific regards to privileges within the #NFT-General-Chat. At this juncture, the community has discussed and concluded that all ‘8/8 holders’ should be granted access to this channel. The main issue currently under discussion is whether this access should be ‘Read Only’ or ‘Read & Write’ in nature.

Read Only Access:

8/8 holders will be invited to participate in an onboarding process which will include a review of our code of conduct and conclude with a claimable erc-1155 token which will confer ‘Read Only Access’ to the #NFT-General-Chat. These holders will be able to drop emojis but will otherwise be unable to write in this channel. Access will be limited to the #NFT-General-Chat & #Alpha-Leaks channels, the latter of which is read only to the entire community by default.

Read & Write Access:

8/8 holders will be invited to participate in an onboarding process which will include a review of our code of conduct and conclude with a claimable erc-1155 token which will confer unencumbered access to the #NFT-General-Chat. These holders will be able to fully participate in this channel just like any other member of FWB. Notably, this will include the permission to post messages and replies. Access will be limited to the #NFT-General-Chat & #Alpha-Leaks channels, the latter of which is read only to the entire community by default.

NFT Channel Access:

Snapshot: January 1, 2022

‘Read Only Access’ Benefits:

‘Read Only Access’ seeks to maintain the current vibe of the #NFT-General-Chat.

‘Read Only Access’ Drawbacks:

‘Read Only Access’ is less aligned with the way these benefits were originally messaged ‘Read Only Access’ creates tiers of participation that may adversely impact the nuanced dynamics of the #NFT-General-Chat

‘Read & Write Access’ Benefits:

‘Read & Write Access’ allows this group of holders to actively participate and contribute to the #NFT-General-Chat

‘Read & Write Access’ Drawbacks:

‘Read & Write Access’ has the potential to adversely impact token price in the short term

Vote: ‘Read Only Access’, 8/8 holders will be invited to participate in the #NFT-General-Chat with ‘Read Only Access’. These holders will be able to drop emojis but will otherwise be unable to write in this channel. ‘Read & Write Access’, 8/8 holders will be invited to participate in the #NFT-General-Chat with the same privileges as any other member of FWB. Notably, this will include the permission to post messages and replies.